Pixel 8 Pro vs Pixel 9 Pro - My thoughts

When the Pixel 9 series details came out, I started to read up on the differences on the Pixel 8 Pro and Pixel 9 series, I didn't see enough changes to make me feel like I needed to upgrade.  Don't get me wrong, the Pixel 9 is impressive, but I wanted to be practical and try to stick with doing an upgrade on a two year cycle (my last upgrade was Pixel 6 Pro to Pixel 8 Pro).

I actually had a spare Pixel 8 Pro that I was looking to sell, and decided to trade it in for a Pixel 9 Pro.  I figured it would allow me (and a few family members) to try out the 9 Pro.  If no one liked it, then I could just sell it.  If everyone liked it, then hopefully I'll be allowed to keep it!

So to jump right into it here are the main differences I have noticed between the Pixel 8 Pro (P8P) and Pixel 9 Pro (P9P):

Screen size

The screen is smaller, going from 6.7" (P8P) to 6.3" (P9P).  However in day to day use, it really didn't matter that much.  The smaller screen wasn't an issue, and if I am doing something that really needs a big screen I have other devices.

Battery life.  

This is where I really noticed a difference.  The first week I got it, I fully charged it Wednesday night and other than putting it back on charge for like 10 minutes ( to apply an update) I didn't charge it again and the phone still had life on Friday.  I have the "AccuBattery Pro" app on both of my phones, and here are the full battery estimates (keep in mind the P9P data is just based on a few days):

Device: Pixel 8 Pro // Pixel 9 Pro

Screen on: 15h 54m // 19h 53m

Screen off: 63h 41m// 5d 13h

Combined used: 27h 42m // 42h 48m

So this is definitely an area of improvement, and this alone makes me tempted to keep using the Pixel 9 Pro as my daily driver.

Call Notes

So the Pixel 9 Pro has a "Call notes" feature.  I tested it one time, and here are some key takeaways:

• It does let the other party know the call is being recorded.
• It gives a pretty impressive summary of the call.
• It gives a full transcript with the actual call recording.

I could see this feature being very useful when you take calls, but of course some people will not like having the call recorded.

Bottom line: At first I wasn't going to upgrade but based on the great deals I ended up getting a Pixel 9 Pro XL!